diff --git a/local-zfs.adoc b/local-zfs.adoc index fd03e89..5b36f5e 100644 --- a/local-zfs.adoc +++ b/local-zfs.adoc @@ -151,6 +151,101 @@ rpool/swap 4.25G 7.69T 64K - ---- +[[sysadmin_zfs_raid_considerations]] +ZFS RAID Level Considerations +~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ + +There are a few factors to take into consideration when choosing the layout of +a ZFS pool. The basic building block of a ZFS pool is the virtual device, or +`vdev`. All vdevs in a pool are used equally and the data is striped among them +(RAID0). Check the `zpool(8)` manpage for more details on vdevs. + +[[sysadmin_zfs_raid_performance]] +Performance +^^^^^^^^^^^ + +Each `vdev` type has different performance behaviors. The two +parameters of interest are the IOPS (Input/Output Operations per Second) and +the bandwidth with which data can be written or read. + +A 'mirror' vdev (RAID1) will approximately behave like a single disk in regards +to both parameters when writing data. When reading data if will behave like the +number of disks in the mirror. + +A common situation is to have 4 disks. When setting it up as 2 mirror vdevs +(RAID10) the pool will have the write characteristics as two single disks in +regard of IOPS and bandwidth. For read operations it will resemble 4 single +disks. + +A 'RAIDZ' of any redundancy level will approximately behave like a single disk +in regard of IOPS with a lot of bandwidth. How much bandwidth depends on the +size of the RAIDZ vdev and the redundancy level. + +For running VMs, IOPS is the more important metric in most situations. + + +[[sysadmin_zfs_raid_size_space_usage_redundancy]] +Size, Space usage and Redundancy +^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ + +While a pool made of 'mirror' vdevs will have the best performance +characteristics, the usable space will be 50% of the disks available. Less if a +mirror vdev consists of more than 2 disks, for example in a 3-way mirror. At +least one healthy disk per mirror is needed for the pool to stay functional. + +The usable space of a 'RAIDZ' type vdev of N disks is roughly N-P, with P being +the RAIDZ-level. The RAIDZ-level indicates how many arbitrary disks can fail +without losing data. A special case is a 4 disk pool with RAIDZ2. In this +situation it is usually better to use 2 mirror vdevs for the better performance +as the usable space will be the same. + +Another important factor when using any RAIDZ level is how ZVOL datasets, which +are used for VM disks, behave. For each data block the pool needs parity data +which is at least the size of the minimum block size defined by the `ashift` +value of the pool. With an ashift of 12 the block size of the pool is 4k. The +default block size for a ZVOL is 8k. Therefore, in a RAIDZ2 each 8k block +written will cause two additional 4k parity blocks to be written, +8k + 4k + 4k = 16k. This is of course a simplified approach and the real +situation will be slightly different with metadata, compression and such not +being accounted for in this example. + +This behavior can be observed when checking the following properties of the +ZVOL: + + * `volsize` + * `refreservation` (if the pool is not thin provisioned) + * `used` (if the pool is thin provisioned and without snapshots present) + +---- +# zfs get volsize,refreservation,used /vm--disk-X +---- + +`volsize` is the size of the disk as it is presented to the VM, while +`refreservation` shows the reserved space on the pool which includes the +expected space needed for the parity data. If the pool is thin provisioned, the +`refreservation` will be set to 0. Another way to observe the behavior is to +compare the used disk space within the VM and the `used` property. Be aware +that snapshots will skew the value. + +There are a few options to counter the increased use of space: + +* Increase the `volblocksize` to improve the data to parity ratio +* Use 'mirror' vdevs instead of 'RAIDZ' +* Use `ashift=9` (block size of 512 bytes) + +The `volblocksize` property can only be set when creating a ZVOL. The default +value can be changed in the storage configuration. When doing this, the guest +needs to be tuned accordingly and depending on the use case, the problem of +write amplification if just moved from the ZFS layer up to the guest. + +Using `ashift=9` when creating the pool can lead to bad +performance, depending on the disks underneath, and cannot be changed later on. + +Mirror vdevs (RAID1, RAID10) have favorable behavior for VM workloads. Use +them, unless your environmanet has specific needs and charactersitics where +RAIDZ performance characteristics are acceptable. + + Bootloader ~~~~~~~~~~